Who Does It Better? Ciara or J. Lewis?

After several push backs, Ciara's fourth studio album Basic Instinct will be released on November 2nd (according to her website... though Amazon is showing a December 14th release date).  A new song has leaked and it struck me as quite familiar... because I heard it first by a man named J.Lewis.  Shut 'Em Up is a rhythmic driven song for Ciara to finally tell her haters out there to piss off.  Lyric highlights include:

They say I’m Hollywood, They think that I’m too good, Just handling my business, Where I live don’t make a difference.

When I make my booty pop, I Shut Em Up 

This song hasn't been confirmed to be on her upcoming album - nor can you really find what her entire track listing will be.  J.Lewis must have sold the rights to Ciara, or at the very least, she's done a demo track of it.  It's still stands to be a mystery (hence the setbacks on the release date I'm sure).  I've always had a place in my heart for Ciara.  She's got fierce attitude, an incredible body (thanks to her near perfect dance moves) and always seems to put out some good stuff.  Though, I gotta say, I love the J. Lewis version better.  Which do you prefer?


Ciara "Shut Em Up"

J. Lewis "Shut Em Up"

And check out this incredible DJ Mashup below!  Best of both worlds & what they should release!